Problems with SSLin Putty

Hello, I’m having issues logging into my Ubuntu Server, through SSH in Putty, after setting up Duo for Unix. It sends the authentication push to my phone with no issues. But after I click approve, the Putty screen says “Access denied” and I get an error pop-up that says "No supported authentication methods available (servers sent: keyboard-interactive). Does anyone have any suggestions?

Also, if I try to log in from the Web Console of VMWare I do not get this authentication error, and I can log in with no issues.